Sunday, January 13, 2013

Proportional Representation

Rob Richie and Devin McCarthy argue that gerrymandered districts aren't the only problem with the House of Representatives.  Single-member, winner-take-all districts don't accurately reflect the partisan balance of a state.  The Center for Voting and Democracy has a plan to bring fair voting and proportional representation to Congress using multi-seat districts.

Update (January 13):  A visual history of Congress from xkcd.

Update (August 3):  Two articles that argue gerrymandering has less impact than commonly believed.

Update (October 20):  The effect of gerrymandering is overstated, but has worked to reduce the number of "wasted" votes in Republican districts.


Also, the number of "Highly Partisan Districts" has increased, leaving fewer competitive seats.


Update (March 26, 2016):  Paul Rosenberg explains how pluralities are hurting Republicans in the presidential primary. The solution is ranked choice voting (instant runoff) and is being promoted by FairVote (formerly the Center for Democracy and Voting).

Update (April 2, 2016):  The Republican State Leadership Committee has a report called “How a Strategy of Targeting State Legislative Races in 2010 Led to a Republican U.S. House Majority in 2013”. The effort to gerrymander Congressional districts was appropriately called REDMAP.

Update (June 13, 2016):  David Daley discusses his book about REDMAP.
[T]he Republicans [may] have interest in fixing the system as well. After all, this last gerrymander locked in control, but it changed the nature of the party base and led to a very extreme House Freedom Caucus and took the ability to manage the caucus and the Congress away from the establishment. It’s among the factors that created the conditions under which [the nominee] could walk away with the party. ... We ignore these issues at our extreme peril — as we have seen these last several years of inaction and decay.
Update (February 10, 2018):  David Daley has an updated story on how Republicans rigged Congress.

Update (June 12, 2018):  Daley explains the statistic evidence used to show how there's nothing "natural" about a Republican advantage in redistricting.
Republicans defended the maps in federal court by suggesting the GOP advantage was “unavoidable” due to clustered Democrats and more evenly spread Republicans. Any districting plan, they argued, would favor Republicans naturally. They presented expert testimony, however, that the court found wholly inadequate to explain the historic Republican lean over two cycles on these maps. If the geographic advantage was inevitable, the Court suggested, it must not be possible to draw any maps without that partisan slant. But Republican mapmakers had produced “multiple alternative plans” without that dramatic bent, despite the modest pro-GOP geography. Fair maps could be drawn, despite Wisconsin’s political geography. Republicans drew them — but merely to use them as a starting point.
Update (June 18, 2018):  The Supreme Court declined to rule in the Wisconsin case by questioning whether plaintiffs in one district had standing to challenge the entire state map.

Update (June 19, 2018):  After the Court non-decision, David Daley expects gerrymandering in 2020 to be even worse. Which leaves Republicans entrenched and the Court unchanged for the foreseeable future.

Update (May 6, 2019):  Courts in Michigan and Ohio have thrown out gerrymandered maps. David Daley explains the significance.
One by one, these maps are being deemed unconstitutional. Only it’s now 2019, and Republicans in all these states, and in Congress, have had a decade to institute policies and install judges, despite repeatedly earning fewer votes on maps found to violate the First and 14th Amendments. Voting rights, labor rights, reproductive rights, the environment — gerrymandered legislatures have assaulted them all nationwide, moving the country backward, in opposition to public will, at a crucial moment in history.
Update (June 28, 2019):  In a 5 to 4 decision, the Supreme Court will allow states to destroy representative government. Justice Elena Kagan dissents:
The partisan gerrymanders in these cases deprived citizens of the most fundamental of their constitutional rights: the rights to participate equally in the political process, to join with others to advance political beliefs, and to choose their political representatives.
In so doing, the partisan gerrymanders here debased and dishonored our democracy, turning upside-down the core American idea that all governmental power derives from the people. These gerrymanders enabled politicians to entrench themselves in office as against voters' preferences. They promoted partisanship above respect for the popular will. They encouraged a politics of polarization and dysfunction. If left unchecked, gerrymanders like the ones here may irreparably damage our system of government.
Update (August 11, 2019):  David Daley interviews Representative Don Beyer about the Fair Representation Act. It would establish multiple members districts for Congress.

Update (September 3, 2019):  A state court has ruled that North Carolina's legislative districts violate the state constitution.

Update (October 31, 2019):  State judges have ruled that North Carolina's Congressional districts violate the state constitution.

Update (December 31, 2019):  David Daley explains the connections between gerrymandered districts and voter suppression.
Here’s the thing: When you’re trying to ensure that the side with less support continues to hold power, when you’re trying to maintain control without talking to a changing nation, your tactics aren’t likely to end with redistricting. Indeed, efforts to make it harder for citizens to vote were among the very first actions by gerrymandered state legislatures, especially in Wisconsin and North Carolina, where a federal court found that those barriers were "surgically" crafted to target blacks. Gerrymandered legislatures can take such anti-democratic actions because the people’s representatives need not fear the judgement of the people. And after the U.S. Supreme Court undid essential protections within the Voting Rights Act, in the 2013 case Shelby County v. Holder, states and other entities didn’t have to fear the courts, either, when they wanted to change the rules around voting. Across much of the nation, but especially in the South, as well as in states with one-party control and newly gerrymandered legislatures, came a flood of voter ID bills, cutbacks in absentee and early voting, voter roll purges, precinct closures and more.
Gerrymandered legislatures felt free to ignore the will of the people.

Tuesday, January 8, 2013

Record Temperature

The contiguous United States experienced a record high mean temperature in 2012.  The new record of 55.32 degrees Fahrenheit exceeded the previous record set in 1998 by more than a degree.


Wednesday, January 2, 2013

Heartless Bastards

Even the biggest Republican assholes see a role for government when it comes to relief from natural disasters.  Not so much when it comes to relief from man made disasters.  To see value in that sort of government intervention means conceding that capitalism isn't everything it's cracked up to be.

Tuesday, December 18, 2012

Extreme Poverty

I'm just now seeing articles about a study by Kathryn Edin and H. Luke Shaefer published by the National Poverty Center at the University of Michigan which reports that the poorest of the poor has increased 130 percent since 1996 in the United States.


Two dollars per person per day is used to describe "moderate" poverty in developing nations in the sense that local currency is converted to purchasing power parity.  The World Bank doesn't even list data for the United States.  It's a standard of living that seems impossible, even as people move in and out of this category month to month.  The worldwide estimate for 2008 was 2.7 billion people living on $2 per day or less.

Monday, December 17, 2012

Peak Need for Farmland

"Peak Farmland" is the phrase used by authors from Rockefeller University's Program for the Human Environment to refer to the trend that less farmland will be needed to due higher crop yields and stabilizing populations.  They estimate that an area the size of ten Iowas could be taken out of production by 2060.

This phrasing isn't parallel to "Peak Oil" which refers to geological limits on oil production.

And the authors' assumptions seem troubling:  Can yields continue to rise if past results depended heavily on oil based fertilizers?  Biofuel production has already contributed to rising food prices -- is a slow rise in production reasonable in the face of peak oil?  Does it make sense to not factor in the impacts of climate change on food production?

It's not that I want to be pessimistic, but we need a realistic analysis for how issues like energy, climate, and food production intertwine.

Update (December 21):  Impacts of Climate Change on Biodiversity, Ecosystems, and Ecosystem Services "documents how climate change is already causing rapid, massive changes."

Update (January 8, 2013):  More about the impact of climate change on food production.

Update (January 19, 2013):  New studies predict falling harvests and rising food price in the face of unchecked climate change.

Update (January 31, 2013):  World grain production and grain stocks dropped in 2012.

Update (April 20, 2013):  An overview of indications that climate change will create a global food crisis.

Update (November 1, 2013):  A report from the World Resources Institute finds that over one-fourth of the world's cropland is experiencing high water-stress.


Update (November 3, 2013):  More about water scarcity.

Update (January 12, 2014):  Peak water is the major constraint on food supplies.

Update (December 20, 2014):  A study published in Environmental Research Letters says that food production could decrease 18 percent by 2050.  Climate change could restrict water supply due to changing precipitation patterns.

Monday, December 10, 2012

Censorship in the United States

While it's been long established that someone like Noam Chomsky will never be seen on network TV, even long time centrist insiders like Thomas Mann and Norman Ornstein can get banished for speaking unthinkable thoughts.  Their crime?  Pointing out that the dysfunction in American politics is largely caused by the Republican Party.

Froomkin quotes Ornstein:
I can't recall a campaign where I've seen more lying going on -- and it wasn't symmetric.  It's the great unreported big story of American politics.

Saturday, December 8, 2012